Stopped by again for a much needed cookie and their rotating flavors. The line moved quick and service was friendly. I got the chocolate covered pretzel cookie, which even the next morning was chewy on the outside and soft on the inside. The cookie had just the right amount of chocolate and salt. The store is always a bit loud and crowded so try not to bring a ton of bags with you or people who aren't getting cookies.

Saw people lining up outside and immediately knew this was a good place! I also learned that they have different flavors every month. There's a lot to choose from and they also serve shakes and coffee

We decided to bring some treats to share on our flight back home so we picked up some cookies at Schmakary's. I heard we are getting a Schmakarys in California?! Anyways, we ordered a variety of cookies to share.... The Classic -chocolate chunks and sea salt. Cookies & Cream- Oreos / Dark Cocoa / Homemade Vanilla Frosting Dulce de Leche - homemade dulce de leche caramel and dusted with cinnamon sugar. Oatmeal Scotchie -oats, creamy butterscotch, vanilla and a pinch of cinnamon Sch'mores - honey graham base, chocolate chunks and topped with roasted marshmallow Peanut Butter Cup -semisweet chocolate and crunchy peanut butter Turtle Snaps -chewy caramel and semisweet chocolate, with toasted pecans and a dash of sea salt. Apple crisp cookie I think all the cookies in general were yummy. I don't think you can go wrong with any choice. My favorite out of all of them was probably the Turtle Snaps and apple crisp. Traveling to California, the Sch'mores did not do well as the cookie stuck to the paper. We shared cookies with the crew and they loved it too.

"The chocolate duet was soooooo nomnomnom. It was definitely one of the best cookies i've ever had! It was so squishy and good! I loved the marshmallows and white chocolate inside, they definitely went well with the regular chocolate! Next time I come, (which there DEFINITELY will be a next time) I am gonna try the Cookies and Cream one, it looked soooo nomnomnom." - 9y ld I had the Cereal Killer & that was the best choice for me! Delicious! Great treat after watching a Broadway show.

WOW I got to try an Oreo cookie and also a peanut butter one and they were both 100/10!!! Some of the best cookies I've ever had and I'm a cookie snob. Oreo - wow you could taste the butter, hint of salt, layer of Oreo, cocoa cookie base... incredible!! Peanut butter - the absolute perfect texture, sweetened, peanut butter flavor and nutty texture. Amazing!! Can't wait to try more!!

These cookies were still chewy and still tasted fresh for 1 day -- can you believe it? The Classic honestly might be the definition of a perfect chocolate chip cookie. The Wizards Brew and Caramel Apple Crisp are both unique flavors that aren't overly sweet. The service was quick, so my friend and I were in and out in no time. There wasn't a long line or too many people after dinnertime, which was a good thing because the shop was pretty small.

While there seem to be a few locations I went to this Schmacmary's which was pretty busy on a a Friday night with a line out the door. Once I made it inside I got to see the cookie options available while listening to some fun music. The staff seemed to be pretty busy and moved everyone through the line pretty quickly. I enjoyed the Strawberry Rhubarb and Classic Chocolate Chip to be great but wasn't a huge fan of the Oatmeal Scotchie.

This place was recommended to me as having one of the best chocolate chip cookies in the world. I will say it did not disappoint! I also ordered a "devil's food cake" cookie, which I found to be too dense.

Great cookies!!! Wanted something sweet, and we found this cute place on yelp. They have a variety of cookies, drinks, and a few pastries. We ordered the cookies and cream, the chocolate chip, and the white chocolate macadamia, and the carrots cake slice. My husband wasn't a fan of the carrot cake, but I really enjoyed the cookies. They were soft and chewy in the center, and a little crunchy on the outside. The employees were very friendly and welcoming. The place is tiny, so if it gets busy, the line might extend to the outside.

Even after all the years these cookies are so darn tasty. After attending an off Broadway event tonight I dropped in for a treat to take home. The chocolate cookie with peppermint frosting and the chocolate hot spice cookie were my choices and both were delish! What's even better was that it was 2 for 1 tonight! Score!