Schmackary's Menu
Schmackary's, located in New York, offers a wide range of delicious cookies with rotating flavors every month. Customers rave about the chewy yet soft cookies, like the chocolate-covered pretzel and the classic chocolate chunk with sea salt. The variety is impressive, from Cookies & Cream to Dulce de Leche and Peanut Butter Cup. The Turtle Snaps and apple crisp are highly recommended by patrons. The cookies are described as perfect in texture and flavor, with unique combinations like the Oreo cookie with a hint of salt and the creamy peanut butter cookie. Schmackary's is known for its friendly service and quick line, making it a must-visit for cookie enthusiasts and a great treat after a Broadway show.
Monday's Cookies
The Classic
Far from average, forever a classic, Packed with gourmet chocolate chunks and a hint of coarse sea salt.
Funfetti
Butter, Sugar, Flour... Plus mountains of sprinkles. Topped with our famous frosting.
Red Velvet
Rich and Velvety. Stuffed with semisweet and white chocolate. Finished with silky vanilla frosting.
Chocolate Explosion
A sinfully rich chocolate base loaded up on semisweet chocolate and topped with our fudgy chocolate frosting.
Dulce De Leche
Abuela approved! This cookie is made with homemade dulce de leche caramel and dusted with cinnamon sugar.
Winter Cherry Crumble
She’s chunky, funky and oh so delicious! Montmorency tart cherries, creamy white chocolate & a dash of cinnamon topped with streusel!
Caramel Delight
A chewy chocolate cookie with a blend of sweet coconut flakes, toffee bits and a smidge of caramel. What a delight!
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Just like a ripened strawberry dipped in decadent chocolate, this cookie will take your tastebuds on a journey and leave you begging for more!
Turtle Snaps
A teenage mutant ninja cookie! Gobs of chewy caramel and semisweet chocolate blend together with a crunch of toasted pecans and a dash of sea salt. contains nuts
The Peanut Gallery
How many ways do we put peanuts into this cookie? THREE! With chips, chunks and good old fashioned PB. And Critics agree. This peanut butter cookie is a smash hit!
Strawberries & Cream
Sun ripened strawberries paired with creamy white chocolate! This gluten-free gem is a sweet surrender you wont soon forget.
Earl Of Chocolate
Calm your senses with each bite. Earl Grey tea, mixed with candied orange peel and semisweet chocolate. vegan
Best Sellers
A pre-assorted dozen box of our best selling flavors: Classic Chocolate Chip Funfetti Cookies & Cream
Daily Dozen
An assortment of all flavors we have on in today's rotation.
Classically Classic
It's a classic for a reason! A box of Classic Chocolate Chip cookies, for the cookie purist in you.
Cookie Flights
Cookie Cakes
Classically Classic Cookie Cake
PLEASE ALLOW HOURS NOTICE FOR CAKES. Layers of our famous Classic Chocolate Chip cookies filled and topped in vanilla cream cheese frosting. It gets the Cookie Monster seal of approval!!
Funfetti Cookie Cake
PLEASE ALLOW HOURS NOTICE FOR CAKES. Your favorite cookie, now offered as a -tier cookie cake! Funfetti cookies, layered with vanilla cream cheese frosting and mountains of sprinkles on top!
The Classic
Far from average, forever a classic, Packed with gourmet chocolate chunks and a hint of coarse sea salt.
Funfetti
Butter, Sugar, Flour... Plus mountains of sprinkles. Topped with our famous frosting.
Red Velvet
Rich and Velvety. Stuffed with semisweet and white chocolate. Finished with silky vanilla frosting.
Sch'mores
Taste the campfire with our honey graham base, packed full of chocolate chunks and topped with roasted marshmallow!
Ginger Rogers
The poetic blend of spices in this chewy glazed ginger molasses cookie will have your taste buds dancing cheek to cheek.
Oatmeal Scotchie
This combination of oats, creamy butterscotch, vanilla and a pinch of cinnamon is practically perfection.
Caramel Delight
A chewy chocolate cookie with a blend of sweet coconut flakes, toffee bits and a smidge of caramel. What a delight!
Mocha Java
White Island
White Chocolate + Macadamia Nut and then add sweet coconut for texture! When can I move to this island?!
Peanut Butter After Dark
A chocolate-peanut butter dream come true, with semisweet chocolate peanut butter chips and Reese’s Pieces.
Sweet Corn∆
Inspired by Southern cornbread, this Sweet + Savory combo, stuffed with toasted pecans & cranberries pleases even the most discerning taste buds. contains nuts ∆gluten free
Cookie Butter Bliss
Cookie butter straight from the jar and into a chewy delight with notes of warm cinnamon. You’ll never believe its vegan!
Tuesday's Cookies
Wednesday's Cookies
The Classic
Far from average, forever a classic, Packed with gourmet chocolate chunks and a hint of coarse sea salt.
Funfetti
Butter, Sugar, Flour... Plus mountains of sprinkles. Topped with our famous frosting.
Red Velvet
Rich and Velvety. Stuffed with semisweet and white chocolate. Finished with silky vanilla frosting.
Chocolate Explosion
A sinfully rich chocolate base loaded up on semisweet chocolate and topped with our fudgy chocolate frosting.
Dulce De Leche
Abuela approved! This cookie is made with homemade dulce de leche caramel and dusted with cinnamon sugar.
Oatmeal Scotchie
This combination of oats, creamy butterscotch, vanilla and a pinch of cinnamon is practically perfection.
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Just like a ripened strawberry dipped in decadent chocolate, this cookie will take your tastebuds on a journey and leave you begging for more!
Rocky Road
Rocky Road Cookie
White Island
White Chocolate + Macadamia Nut and then add sweet coconut for texture! When can I move to this island?!
Vegan Peanut Butter Cup
Packed with semisweet chocolate and loads of crunchy peanut butter. It’s simply peanut butter bliss. contains nuts
Stay Gold^
A reminder to savor life's sweet moments, this cookie contains freshly zested lemon, creamy lemon morsels and topped with a lemon creamsicle frosting. ^gluten free
Yogi Bare∆
A cookie fit for the trail! Brimming with peanut butter, oats∆, raisins, craisins, nuts & seeds.
The Classic
Far from average, forever a classic, Packed with gourmet chocolate chunks and a hint of coarse sea salt.
Funfetti
Butter, Sugar, Flour... Plus mountains of sprinkles. Topped with our famous frosting.
Red Velvet
Rich and Velvety. Stuffed with semisweet and white chocolate. Finished with silky vanilla frosting.
Sch'mores
Taste the campfire with our honey graham base, packed full of chocolate chunks and topped with roasted marshmallow!
Dulce De Leche
Abuela approved! This cookie is made with homemade dulce de leche caramel and dusted with cinnamon sugar.
Winter Cherry Crumble
She’s chunky, funky and oh so delicious! Montmorency tart cherries, creamy white chocolate & a dash of cinnamon topped with streusel!
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Just like a ripened strawberry dipped in decadent chocolate, this cookie will take your tastebuds on a journey and leave you begging for more!
Mocha Java
Sweet Corn∆
Inspired by Southern cornbread, this Sweet + Savory combo, stuffed with toasted pecans & cranberries pleases even the most discerning taste buds. contains nuts ∆gluten free
Peanut Butter After Dark
A chocolate-peanut butter dream come true, with semisweet chocolate peanut butter chips and Reese’s Pieces.
Stay Gold^
A reminder to savor life's sweet moments, this cookie contains freshly zested lemon, creamy lemon morsels and topped with a lemon creamsicle frosting. ^gluten free
Earl Of Chocolate
Calm your senses with each bite. Earl Grey tea, mixed with candied orange peel and semisweet chocolate. vegan
Thursday's Cookies
Friday's Cookies
The Classic
Far from average, forever a classic, Packed with gourmet chocolate chunks and a hint of coarse sea salt.
Funfetti
Butter, Sugar, Flour... Plus mountains of sprinkles. Topped with our famous frosting.
Red Velvet
Rich and Velvety. Stuffed with semisweet and white chocolate. Finished with silky vanilla frosting.
Chocolate Explosion
A sinfully rich chocolate base loaded up on semisweet chocolate and topped with our fudgy chocolate frosting.
Ginger Rogers
The poetic blend of spices in this chewy glazed ginger molasses cookie will have your taste buds dancing cheek to cheek.
Oatmeal Scotchie
This combination of oats, creamy butterscotch, vanilla and a pinch of cinnamon is practically perfection.
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Just like a ripened strawberry dipped in decadent chocolate, this cookie will take your tastebuds on a journey and leave you begging for more!
Mocha Java
Turtle Snaps
A teenage mutant ninja cookie! Gobs of chewy caramel and semisweet chocolate blend together with a crunch of toasted pecans and a dash of sea salt. contains nuts
Vegan Peanut Butter Cup
Packed with semisweet chocolate and loads of crunchy peanut butter. It’s simply peanut butter bliss. contains nuts
Strawberries & Cream
Sun ripened strawberries paired with creamy white chocolate! This gluten-free gem is a sweet surrender you wont soon forget.
Cookie Butter Bliss
Cookie butter straight from the jar and into a chewy delight with notes of warm cinnamon. You’ll never believe its vegan!
The Classic
Far from average, forever a classic, Packed with gourmet chocolate chunks and a hint of coarse sea salt.
Funfetti
Butter, Sugar, Flour... Plus mountains of sprinkles. Topped with our famous frosting.
Red Velvet
Rich and Velvety. Stuffed with semisweet and white chocolate. Finished with silky vanilla frosting.
Chocolate Explosion
A sinfully rich chocolate base loaded up on semisweet chocolate and topped with our fudgy chocolate frosting.
Dulce De Leche
Abuela approved! This cookie is made with homemade dulce de leche caramel and dusted with cinnamon sugar.
Oatmeal Scotchie
This combination of oats, creamy butterscotch, vanilla and a pinch of cinnamon is practically perfection.
Caramel Delight
A chewy chocolate cookie with a blend of sweet coconut flakes, toffee bits and a smidge of caramel. What a delight!
Rocky Road
Rocky Road Cookie
White Island
White Chocolate + Macadamia Nut and then add sweet coconut for texture! When can I move to this island?!
Yogi Bare∆
A cookie fit for the trail! Brimming with peanut butter, oats∆, raisins, craisins, nuts & seeds.
Strawberries & Cream
Sun ripened strawberries paired with creamy white chocolate! This gluten-free gem is a sweet surrender you wont soon forget.
Cookie Butter Bliss
Cookie butter straight from the jar and into a chewy delight with notes of warm cinnamon. You’ll never believe its vegan!
Saturday's Cookies
Sunday's Cookies
The Classic
Far from average, forever a classic, Packed with gourmet chocolate chunks and a hint of coarse sea salt.
Funfetti
Butter, Sugar, Flour... Plus mountains of sprinkles. Topped with our famous frosting.
Red Velvet
Rich and Velvety. Stuffed with semisweet and white chocolate. Finished with silky vanilla frosting.
Sch'mores
Taste the campfire with our honey graham base, packed full of chocolate chunks and topped with roasted marshmallow!
Ginger Rogers
The poetic blend of spices in this chewy glazed ginger molasses cookie will have your taste buds dancing cheek to cheek.
Caramel Delight
A chewy chocolate cookie with a blend of sweet coconut flakes, toffee bits and a smidge of caramel. What a delight!
Rocky Road
Rocky Road Cookie
Turtle Snaps
A teenage mutant ninja cookie! Gobs of chewy caramel and semisweet chocolate blend together with a crunch of toasted pecans and a dash of sea salt. contains nuts
The Peanut Gallery
How many ways do we put peanuts into this cookie? THREE! With chips, chunks and good old fashioned PB. And Critics agree. This peanut butter cookie is a smash hit!
Sweet Corn∆
Inspired by Southern cornbread, this Sweet + Savory combo, stuffed with toasted pecans & cranberries pleases even the most discerning taste buds. contains nuts ∆gluten free
Earl Of Chocolate
Calm your senses with each bite. Earl Grey tea, mixed with candied orange peel and semisweet chocolate. vegan
Winter Cherry Crumble
She’s chunky, funky and oh so delicious! Montmorency tart cherries, creamy white chocolate & a dash of cinnamon topped with streusel!
Coffee
Cafe Au Lait
Coffee Traveler
oz coffee traveler. Cups, Milk & Sweetener included.
Tea
Coffee/Tea
Espresso
Latte
Cappuccino
Espresso
Americano
Macchiato
Flat White
Cafe Mocha
Iced Latte
Iced Americano
Iced Mocha
Chai Latte
Matcha Latte
Apple Cider
Hot Chocolate
London Fog
Golden Milk
Iced Chai Latte
Iced Matcha Latte
Specialty
Milk
Whole Milk
oz
Skim Milk
oz
Almond Milk
oz
Oat Milk
oz
Chocolate Milk
oz
